Rough Theory

Theory In The Rough

Category Archives: Overheard

Reading Group Reunited

So the reading group held its first in-person meeting in a month today. We caught up on one another’s US adventures (and the slightly less adventurous things that occured in Australia), and we discussed academic politics, the popularity of certain theoretical traditions within specific academic fields, barriers to interdisciplinary work, our fears about whether anyone is now reading, or ever will read, our work and, occasionally, even Steven Pinker’s Language Instinct. I’ll leave Pinker aside for the moment, as *nudge* G. Gollings intends to introduce the online discussion of this work. I’m also simply too exhausted to summarise the rest of our substantive discussion, though I feel a bit guilty about this, as we really did manage to cover a lot of ground in interesting and productive ways – I feel like I should have brought a tape recorder. Then again…

While we wait on the official Pinker thread (no pressure, of course… ;-P), I’ll content myself here with a few conversational snippets taken out of context:

The travel tales began with an appropriately poetic introduction: “America is of course one of the world’s great works of fiction…”

The end of the trip, however, was not as poetic as the beginning, with the story moving through a detailed description of the labyrinthine and cryptic baggage handling procedures required to depart from LAX, leading to the observation: “It was like a big ‘Fuck you!’ on your way out of the country.”

In spite of the many temptations and distractions during their trip, the reading group members had remained in occasional touch with the blog, and had noticed from afar – very far afar, from the sounds of it – the recent influx of Lacanian themes. The reading group members expressed their concern, and have offered technical assistance: “You know, that’s the second-worst problem on the web right now, after spam – we’re developing software to take care of that.”

In the end, our catch-up chat was quite protracted, and the wait staff were impressed – if not by the breadth or depth, then at least by the duration – of our conversation, and commented when we surrendered our table: “Well, that was a long discussion.”

Revolt from the Margins

I’ve been re-reading Friedman’s Capitalism and Freedom recently – a dog-eared copy from the library, filled with underlines, highlights and an extended argument against the book scattered through the margins of the text. The marginal commentary has one dominant voice – a voice very, very unhappy with Friedman – and, for some reason, fixated on the notion that the existence of stagflation disproves Friedman’s points. I’ve been following the evolution of this marginal critique through the book – watching substantive points alternate with angry outbursts of “No!”. As the book progresses, the angry outbursts become more frequent – the handwriting more tense. I found myself skipping ahead of the text to see how this marginal conflict would end. I wasn’t disappointed. There on the last page of the book, underneath another burst of irritation at how Friedman should pay more attention to stagflation, is the final verdict:

I’m right. Jerk – bugger you!”

Not Sure How to Feel…

I’m not really sure how to feel about the person who found this site by searching under “random thoughts of great minds”, clicked on a few pages, and then exited to follow the link titled “what in the hell…”

Overheard at the Office: User Pays

When I was just winding things up at the office this evening, a security guard came by on their regular rounds. After several months of startled reactions, the security folks have finally gotten used to seeing me in the building at odd hours, and generally now poke in to chat for a couple of minutes before wandering on their way. Today’s conversation topic was the after-hours ventilation system, which I tend not to turn on when I’m in the office alone, as it seems a tad… profligate to air condition an entire floor for my singular comfort.

Security officer: “Bit stuffy in here, isn’t it?”

Me: “Oh, it probably is – I don’t think I turned on the ventilation system.”

Security officer: “Well, I can do it.”

Me: “No, it’s not a problem – I’m about to leave anyway.”

Security officer, walking out of sight: “No, really, it’s no problem.” Clonk – whrrrrmph! “It’s not like you’re payin’ for it…”

Overheard at the Research Meeting

Selections of conversation from a meeting this evening, intended as a venue for sharing updates on PhD research in progress in the Environment and Planning area:

The Tabula Rasa

Setting: a somewhat involved discussion about the process of mapping ontological assumptions prior to beginning an intensive process of qualitative research.

Question: But do you really need to do that, you think, before you actually start doing your research?

Answer: Well, yes – I think you do. I mean, I believe there’s no such thing as the naive researcher…

Hand from the back of the room: Well, I’m pretty close!

Knickers in a Twist

Setting: a discussion of to what degree new technologies will improve compliance with environmental principles.

Argument: I think it also depends on who we’re talking about. I mean, a teenage girl with wet knickers who wants to wear them out that evening, is going to toss them in the dryer. Whereas someone at a different life stage will… will… will…

Interjection: Will go out without wearing any!

First Do No Harm

Setting: a discussion about a housing developments that heavily promote their environmental credentials.

Statement: What about Development X – I mean, I suppose it’s better than nothing…

Response: No. It’s not better than nothing.

Overheard at the Local Restaurant: GI Joe

Man: “I had crumpets for breakfast – they’re really good! They’re low-GI, you know!”

Woman: “Did you have honey on them?”

Man: “Yes.”

Woman: “Jam?”

Man: “A little bit, yeah.”

Woman: “That’s not low-GI then, is it?”

Man: “Oh, well, yeah – but just imagine if I’d had those same toppings on toast!”

Overheard in a University Coffee Shop IV: On the Bright Side

Student One: So, did you like the script?

== long pause ==

Student Two: Well… it was…

Student One: Dark?

Student Two: Well… I thought it was…

Student One: Too dark?

Student Two: No… uh… average…

== long pause ==

Overheard in the Library: Location, Location

Disconsolate student talking into mobile phone: “The task is at home… And I am at school.”

Overheard at the Conference: Words and Things

At least one person seems to share my confusion about theory-as-classification:

Person One: So how was your session?

Person Two: Well, the title didn’t really reflect what it was about. It was really just a semantic discussion trying to home in on what is the definition of community engagement vs. community consultation vs… I mean – how bloody useless! The words aren’t the important thing…

Overheard in a University Coffee Shop III: Simple Pleasures

Man: “Call me simple, but I like to shoot things.”

Design a site like this with WordPress.com
Get started